|
|
||||
‘Diamonds’ Ecological Footprint Reduction:
Preparation of Guidance Material for
Footprint Reduction at Local and Sub-regional Level
| Client: | SEEDA, South East Diamonds for Investment & Growth |
| Donor: | SEEDA |
| Consultancy Partners: | Best Foot Forward, Levett-Therivel, Colin Tingle (The NR Group) |
| Project Management: | Craig Simmons (Best Foot Forward) |
| Consultancy Team: | Craig Simmons, Richard Sheane, Rebeca Laorga [Best Foot Forward], Roger Levett [Levett-Therival], Colin Tingle [The NR Group] |
View as PDF |
|
Ecological footprint (or EF) analysis provides a broad measure of the land and sea area required to sustainably support a particular lifestyle or community. It is measured in world average productive hectares, referred to as ‘global hectares’ (gha). The use of area as an environmental measurement unit makes it a powerful and resonant means of communicating environmental impact and assessing progress towards sustainability. It also allows for benchmarking across cities, regions and nations, highlighting where consumption of energy and materials is exceeding environmental limits and provides a measure for “one planet living” – currently 1.8 gha per person. The UK has an EF of 5.3 gha/person (based on 2004 figures), meaning that if everyone in the world lived like the average UK citizen, we would require almost 3 planets to sustain us all. Lifestyles in the south east of England are even less sustainable, with an average EF of 5.63 gha. |
|
||||||
![]() |
|
||||||
When the area of a country is portrayed as its national ecofootprint expressed as a proportion of the total global ecofootprint, inequities around the globe become starkly clear. |
![]() From: http://assets.panda.org/downloads/living_planet_report.pdf |
||||||
| Background | |
The South East Diamonds for Investment and Growth (SEDfIG) is a coalition of cities, towns and their surrounding areas committed to realising their potential for sustainable economic and community growth in the south east of England. The SE Diamonds originated in South East England Development Agency (SEEDA)'s 2006 Regional Economic Strategy (RES). They were there identified as the 'sub-regional functional areas' with the greatest potential for significant contributions to economic growth in the south east. |
![]() |
| SEEDA’s designation of the SEDfIG was based entirely on economic evaluation – GVA (Gross Value Added) is the dominant feature of the assessment made, alongside a variety of other financial flow data, with no accompanying use of indicators of ecological sustainability. Given the high resource consumption historically involved in delivering conventional GVA growth, the first headline target of the South East Plan (SEEDA, 2007) and RES Implementation Plan - achieving an average annual increase in GVA per capita of at least 3% - is potentially in conflict with the third headline target, which addresses the need to reduce the ecological footprint. | ‘Diamond’ Local authorities are highlighted in red
|
In order to tackle this potential target divergence and through the work of the “Tackling Ecological Footprint (TEF) Policy Group” (see Context below), targets have been adopted by SEDfIG to accelerate reduction of the ecological footprint of the Diamonds and the Local authorities (LAs) within them. To illustrate the extent of the challenge facing the Diamonds in terms of Ecological Footprint (EF), of the top 20 highest footprint local authorities in the UK, five are within the SE Diamonds. Looking at the individual components of the footprint; for housing EF, three out of the top 20 are from the Diamonds; for transport four of the top 20 are from the Diamonds and, for Food, one out of 20 is a Diamond local authority. No Diamond LAs feature in the bottom 20 for overall, housing, food or transport EF. To assist SEDfIG and its component LAs in achieving the accelerated targets they have set for themselves, SEEDA commissioned an ecofootprint (EF) analysis of the Diamonds and the production of Guidance material on reductions in EF, carbon emissions, water use and waste. The primary goal of this project was to offer information of practical assistance to the Diamonds to enable the LAs within them to deliver the challenging, accelerated targets relating to Ecofootprint reduction and natural resource management, agreed by the South East Diamonds leaders. |
|
| Context: |
|||||||||
| The SEDfIG partnership exists across the eight Diamond areas, serving as a forum for the exchange of best practice, research into the impacts and drivers of growth and a platform for lobbying and profile-raising for the Diamond areas. The formulation of executive policy and delivery of sub-regional and local targets rests with the individual Diamond areas and the various partners that constitute them. | |||||||||
This stratified approach is complemented by the work of three SEDfIG policy groups, focused upon:
These groups are designed to share expertise, increase capacity and take forward key challenges through partnership, thereby enhancing local authority capacity. Colin Tingle is a member of the TEF policy group. |
|||||||||
The key aim of this project was to assist individual local authorities in achieving all the Diamond targets through the provision of:
|
|||||||||
Consultancy Roles: |
|
||||
| The Natural Resources Group (in the person of Colin Tingle) are providing consultancy input into the production of the EF analysis and of the Guidance material for Ecofootprint reduction for the South East Diamonds and the Local Authorities located therein. Best Foot Forward led on EF analysis; Levett-Therivel on policy guidance material. Colin led on governance issues relating to EF reduction in SEDfIG and was involved in training other team members in the use of REAP (Resource & Energy Analysis Programme – the EF tool developed by the Stockholm Environment Institute (SEI) & others, identified as that most appropriate for use in this study), researching case study examples of EF reduction policies &/or initiatives for inclusion assessment by Levett-Therivel; researching relevant water consumption data and water footprinting information for use by Best Foot Forward in the EF analysis; researching indicators for EF reduction in relation to National Performance Indicators (NIs); providing input to the reports to SEEDA, including a section on governance relating to Diamonds working groups. |
|||||
| Project outputs: | |
The project report delivers the baseline REAP analyses (which takes a consumption-based approach to footprinting) for the ecological and carbon footprint, supplemented by additional direct carbon emissions, water and waste analyses – all presented for each Diamond.
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
| The initial selection of case studies for inclusion in the Guide is also described with guidance on where to draw on national versus local examples of best practice alongside advice on delivering change; both from the perspective of improving governance and the ongoing monitoring of progress. A further output - a ‘Dashboard tool’ that readily and accessibly display results from the footprint analyses - is also presented. This tool was developed by Best Foot Forward and has been very well received by all that have seen and used it, with the result that it has been additionally provided to SEI for use in displaying all results from REAP in the future. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
Screenshot of REAP Diamonds dashboard tool |
![]() |
||||||||||||||||||
Several recommendations are made on how to best take forward this work; to ensure both widespread dissemination and ease of future reporting.
Guidance material has been provided in the form of a “ No-Nonsense Guide ‘wiki’” to assist the Diamonds and their component LAs to taking policy actions to produce accelerated reduction in their EF and carbon footprints, their water usage and waste production & management. The Guide is designed to
The site is designed to help readers go in to the material at whatever level they wish, from quick overview to strategic decision to practical detail. Each section has a top-level page offering an overview and links to further pages, in the site and/or externally, which give progressively more specialised and detailed information.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
The site map below shows the summary structure. |
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||
The Pages titled “Towards action planning” draw out some messages, under a number of key headings to help Diamonds develop effective action plans Success factors are identified which provide some generic lessons from the range of practice reviewed (at various levels of depth) for the other sections of the Guide. Every example is different, thus judgment has been needed to draw out common threads from projects in different fields, and there may well be counter examples to all the generalisations offered. The lessons are:
each of which is examined and explored so as to identify pointers to stimulate and support action, NOT to provide rules that must be rigidly followed or that can guarantee success. Many points are interconnected. Related pages look at ‘ Exploiting the Opportunities’ to bring about footprint reduction, with sections discussing:
For each of these, we suggest possible actions by Diamonds, by SEEDA and by central Government to bring forward footprint reductions across the various areas identified by the analysis and investigated throughout the Guidance material. As yet, neither the report on the EF analysis nor the No-Nonsense Guide are in the public domain. They are in the process of being rolled out across the Diamonds, as a priority, and will then go into the public domain for wider consumption and use ……. watch this space! |
|||||||||||||||||||
| Links: | |
| Best Foot Forward | www.bestfootforward.com |
| Diamonds study at Best Foot Forward | www.bestfootforward.com/case_study |
| Levett-Therivel | www.levett-therivel.co.uk |
| SEEDA | www.seeda.co.uk |
| SE Diamonds | www.southeastdiamonds.org.uk |
| SE Diamonds Prospectus for Prosperity | www.southeastdiamonds.org.uk/Documents/Leaflet.pdf |
| The NR Group | www.thenrgroup.net |
| Other relevant Ecological Footprint links: | |
| www.resource-accounting.org.uk/ | |
| REAP software tools to help you calculate footprints http://resource-accounting.org.uk/software |
|
| www.ecologicalbudget.org.uk/ | |
| www.bestfootforward.com/ecological_footprint | |
| www.footprintnetwork.org/en/index.php/GFN/ | |
|
Page last updated June 25, 2009 |